A crossbow in one hand and letting rip with fireballs with the other....sold!

I really love What Do You Do With A Drunken Sailor. Excellent choice for trailer music.

It was that out of place it added to the atmosphere, weirdly, I thought . It wasn't sung as a ditty more a sorta dirge.

Hrm.

Unfortunately, even though the setting looks great, the combat does look like bioshock.

It also has a lot of oversaturated colours. It looks absolutely amazing...like you fell into a 1920'es painting by Ed Hopper...but unfortunately, I really dislike this type of look for action gameplay. I found in bioshock that I couldn't actually tell what the enemies were doing very well, because I had to rely on snap decisions and reflexes to get them. The aesthetic was ultimately too confusing when things sped up.

If Dishonored has a hitman-esque path through the game though, that would be amazing. Hitman got away with having way more packed aesthetics without giving me the same issue, for instance during the wedding and the carnival.

Hitman-style gameplay doesn't trailer very well, so it might be a strong component, and if so, I probably can't avoid getting this. Because the setting looks ace - it looks absolutely brilliant. You're V for Vendetta, an anonymous masked killer, and instead of bombs, you just assasinate the shit out of a brutal opressing governments figureheads.

That's a recipe for excitement if I ever saw one.

I agree there was some BioShock to it, but I thought it looked a lot closer to Dark Messiah. Which would be... obvious.

ARGH I cant stand children singing in unison! And I haven't got a clue why either.
Shame the trailer was all Action. Where's interacting with the environment, inventory management and all that other Immersive sim goodness?
Looks like this is gonna be more Dark Messiah than Arx Fatalis. I thought Dark Messiah mostly sucked, well not sucked but it is nothing special.

Hopefully someone will tape the proper e3 presentation that contains some proper gameplay and stuff.

I don't think you understand how trailers work.

When you have a couple of minutes to sell people on your game... you don't want to show them somebody faffing about with the inventory.

The thing is that you totally could show the interface gui for a few seconds. Or the skill tree, or whatever. It doesn't have to be non-stop action all the time. Sneaking is kind of hard though. As is clever solutions to problems and such.

I dunno, if you look at what they did include, it's pretty clear they wanted to have a dramatic and experience-based trailer, they tried to pull you into their world and make you feel like you got a glimpse of existence within their narrative. Popping the inventory up for a while there would kind of undermine the mood. Spooky dramatic music and stabbing people in the throat? Awesome. Spooky dramatic music and inventory tetris? Uhm... eh

Hopefully they'll release some more long-form gameplay footage soon.

Borderlands 2 trailer showed the skill menu etc....Not that i am particularly interested in it. Borderlands 1 was weak, but it's appeal came from playing co-op. I'll probably pick it up cheap, B1 was still fun.

But yeah blood & explosionz will attract the masses best, but it still leaves me with small doubts about the game.

Yeah I went too far there sorry. It was a good game but it was no Arx Fatalis.

God of war has a jump mechanic, that doesn't fit in with Bioware's design paradigms, it's not "awesome" enough apparently.

It also has decent level design, no constant invisible walls, fairly challenging puzzles and combat and it is mostly linear. Yes I prefer linearity to Bioware's terrible level design and forced & predictable pick option a or pick option b approach to choices.

I was going to write a proper reply to you, but then your snark and your sarcasm pissed me off, and I decided it's not worth my time.

Why would YOU get offended? I was dissing the game not you. Cant we agree to disagree?

I wasn't offended, I was pissed.

We can agree to disagree if you agree to present your opinion in a less provocating manner.